Research — instructions for peer reviewers

Give researchers this URL (canonical entry):

https://gaiaftcl.com/Research-Publication/

Short link alias: https://gaiaftcl.com/research/ (redirects to the publication hub)

---

Email / chat copy-paste

GaiaFTCL research publication (ECDLP + QC VM, paper v3, frozen 2026-06-05):

  Hub:     https://gaiaftcl.com/Research-Publication/
  Lean:    https://gaiaftcl.com/Research-Lean-Gates/
  JSON:    https://gaiaftcl.com/evidence/research/qc_vm_validation_latest.json

Clone the repo and reproduce:
  cells/xcode/scripts/peer_review_research_dataset.sh

Honest flags in the frozen export: allMathLayerOK=true, allLeanGatesCalorie=true,
allRewardClaimsOK=false (L7 learning — no chain_accepted block yet).

---

What to open (in order)

Step	URL	What you get
1	Research publication	Paper v3 summary, frozen findings, QC-020 dual path, reproduce commands
2	Research Lean gates	QC-001…QC-021 ↔ `FirstRoars/*.lean` — 31 CALORIE gate receipts
3	Lion Math Artifacts	Full 84-file kernel catalog
4	SHOR ECDLP paper v3	Full paper on mesh wiki
5	Validation JSON	`gaiaftcl.qc_vm.research.v4` + embedded `leanGates`

---

Reproduce locally

git clone https://github.com/gaiaftcl-sudo/gaiaFTCL.git
cd gaiaFTCL

# Metal shaders (required before substrate QC)
cells/xcode/scripts/build_metal_shaders.sh

# Full peer-review export + leak audit + wiki refresh
cells/xcode/scripts/peer_review_research_dataset.sh

Frozen artifacts land in evidence/research/*_latest.json. The mesh serves the same *_latest.json files at /evidence/research/.

---

What we claim (and do not)

Claim	Status
QC-001…QC-021 math layer on `vqbit_metal` (22 pipelines)	`allMathLayerOK=true`
31 Lean kernel gates CALORIE on research export	`allLeanGatesCalorie=true`
ECDLP structured seals (neg-G, generator) on secp256k1	`witnessOK` in evaluation JSON
QC-020 PoW dual path (historical + live miner)	`bothPathsOK=true`
On-chain mining reward at payout	Not claimed — L7 `learning` until `chain_accepted`
Break arbitrary 256-bit mainnet keys	Not claimed — see substrate honest disclosure

---

Mesh vs GitHub

Surface	Use when
https://gaiaftcl.com/Research-Publication/	Default for external reviewers — navigable site + sidebar
https://gaiaftcl.com/wiki/	Lightweight mesh wiki mirror (same content, static HTML)
GitHub `cells/xcode/docs/SHOR_ECDLP_RESEARCH_PAPER.md`	Source-of-truth in repo; mesh is the published render

---

*Operator: after each revalidation run, peer_review_research_dataset.sh refreshes frozen JSON and the Research-Lean-Gates wiki page before mesh deploy.*

Federation cosignature: pending operator signing host (v26). Witness (sha256 of rendered body): 452f73474e21e9afd94e38f95187cc82d5b06066b522f48498af69a5d8fd6d1c. This page serves with a substrate-honest pending-signature notice until the operator's Franklin signer cosigns it.